BAGHDAD — Sometime during my four years of traveling to Iraq,
I developed a recurring dream in which a Middle Eastern country invades
the United States and occupies, among other places, my old neighborhood
on the South Side of Chicago. The dream flashed briefly through my mind
on Thursday as I walked the dirty, broken streets of Sadr City, a
teeming Baghdad slum that forms the power base of Moktada al-Sadr, the radical Shiite cleric....
Alleys: they are dangerous only when used by those who grew up in
them. That is the basic reason Mr. Sadr and his fighters simply will
not go away in this war.
What makes the case so difficult is
that it is not just a question of a battle with American troops, here
from half a world away carrying out operations that Mr. Sadr and his
fighters consider an abhorrent occupation. Some 3,500 troops in the
Basra fight are Iraqis from outside the province, and witnesses say it
is clear that few if any of the Iraqi security forces in the assault
know the neighborhoods the way the Mahdi Army does. Its fighters
literally pop in and out of alleys, battling a federal force of nearly
30,000 to what is, so far, a stalemate.
I'm pretty sure that this sums up the whole fucking mess really well -- one of the first rules of military operations going back to Clausewitz if not earlier is that the map is not the terrain. You don't fight wars on maps. Firefights are not done on 1:25000 scale video display. We have great communications tools, but we can't communicate the immediacy, the smell, the heat, the exhaustion. We can communicate images. This article does a good job of pointing out something -- this is not our home. They don't want us there. We peeled the scab off a gangrenous mess and now it's going crazy.
So, yeah, we can conduct patrols and calm things down. We can brutalize, terrorize and do things that we do not want Americans to do. These guys are doing what John McCain would do if the Mahdi Army took over Sedona. However, I suspect that Bush, Cheney, Wolfowitz, et al would be lining up for those good jobs translating and narcing out the patriots defending the homeland, while talking about how great it all was that the evil Democracy had been overturned by the liberators...
Now, Crusader AXE totally buys into the idea that the sign of a bad policy is when you have no good alternatives. And, I find the ragheaded version of fundamentalism to be as repugnant as our own, if not more so because, at present, we don't have any aggressive, invasive Christian theocracies running around trying to destablize the world. Of course, that's my perception. The boys in the Mahdi Army might have a slightly different perception. And, they haven't landed on Virginia Beach yet...
Recent Comments